Why Your Child's Athletic Mouthguard Should Come From the Dentist (Not the Sporting Goods Store)

Friday night lights, weekend soccer tournaments, basketball games in the gym—San Antonio families know that youth sports are more than just games. They're opportunities for your child to build confidence, develop teamwork skills, and create memories that last a lifetime. But along with all the excitement and achievement comes a sobering reality: sports-related dental injuries are far more common than most parents realize.

At Brooks Pediatric Dentistry & Orthodontics, our board-certified pediatric dentists see the aftermath of preventable dental injuries every season. The difference between a minor scare and a major dental emergency often comes down to one crucial piece of protective equipment—the mouthguard. But not all mouthguards offer equal protection, and that $15 boil-and-bite option from the sporting goods store might be giving you a false sense of security.

The Sobering Statistics Every San Antonio Parent Should Know

Let's start with the numbers, because they tell a compelling story about why mouthguard choice matters. According to the American Dental Association, athletes who don't wear mouthguards are 60 times more likely to suffer dental injuries during sports activities. Sixty times. That's not a small difference—it's the gap between playing it safe and gambling with your child's smile.

Sports-related incidents account for 13-39% of all dental injuries in children and adolescents. The National Youth Sports Foundation for Safety estimates that more than 3 million teeth are knocked out every year in youth sporting events across the United States. Basketball leads boys' sports with a dental injury rate of 2.4 per 100,000 athletic exposures, while field hockey tops the list for girls at 3.5 per 100,000 athletic exposures.

Perhaps most striking: research shows that 50% of kids participating in sports could sustain a dental injury by the time they graduate high school. Half of all young athletes. These aren't rare freak accidents—they're predictable injuries that happen with alarming regularity on fields, courts, and rinks across Brooks City Base and beyond.

The financial impact of a single dental injury adds another layer of concern. A knocked-out permanent tooth can require a lifetime of dental work, with costs easily reaching $20,000 or more for just one tooth. That figure includes the initial emergency treatment, root canal therapy, crown work, and eventually an implant when your child reaches adulthood. Suddenly, investing in proper protection doesn't seem like an expense—it looks like the bargain of a lifetime.

Understanding the Three Types of Mouthguards

When you walk into a sporting goods store, you'll typically encounter one or two types of mouthguards: stock mouthguards that come pre-formed in standard sizes, and boil-and-bite mouthguards that you soften in hot water before molding to your child's teeth. These over-the-counter options are convenient and inexpensive, usually costing between $10 and $60. But convenience and affordability don't equal adequate protection.

Stock mouthguards represent the lowest level of protection available. They come in generic sizes—usually small, medium, or large—and offer no customization whatsoever. Your child essentially has to bite down and hold the mouthguard in place with jaw pressure alone, which makes breathing difficult, speaking nearly impossible, and creates a distraction during play. Most young athletes find stock mouthguards so uncomfortable that they either don't wear them consistently or remove them during critical moments of play.

Boil-and-bite mouthguards represent a step up from stock options. Made from thermoplastic material, these mouthguards soften when placed in boiling water, allowing you to mold them to your child's teeth by biting down while the material is still warm. This process theoretically creates a semi-custom fit, but the reality often falls short of the promise.

The problem with boil-and-bite mouthguards centers on fit precision—or rather, the lack of it. Your mouth can only generate 7-9 pounds per square inch of pressure when biting down, which isn't nearly enough to create the intimate fit necessary for maximum protection. The molding process relies on your child's bite pressure and finger manipulation, which produces inconsistent results. Some areas may fit reasonably well while others remain loose, creating gaps where teeth remain vulnerable to impact.

Custom mouthguards fabricated by your pediatric dentist represent the gold standard in athletic protection. These professional mouthguards are created from precise impressions of your child's unique dental anatomy, then pressed at 120 pounds per square inch during fabrication. This high-pressure process creates an exact replica of your child's teeth and supporting structures, resulting in a fit that boil-and-bite options simply cannot match.

Why Fit Makes All the Difference in Protection

The superior fit of custom mouthguards isn't just about comfort—it's fundamentally about physics and how impacts are absorbed and distributed. When a blow strikes your child's face or jaw, the force needs to be dispersed across the largest possible surface area to minimize damage. A properly fitted custom mouthguard makes intimate contact with every tooth surface, the surrounding gum tissue, and the supporting bone structure, creating maximum surface area for impact absorption.

Research published in dental traumatology journals consistently demonstrates that custom-made mouthguards outperform boil-and-bite options in objective testing. A study comparing basketball players wearing custom mouthguards versus boil-and-bite guards found that custom options showed significantly superior ratings for comfort, stability, breathing, speaking ability, and overall wearability. The boil-and-bite group reported progressive deterioration in comfort and function over the course of the study, while custom mouthguard users maintained consistent positive ratings.

The Australian Dental Association has gone so far as to identify boil-and-bite mouthguards as potential choking hazards, particularly in high-impact sports. Because these mouthguards don't fit securely, they can dislodge during play and potentially block airways. AFL (Australian Football League) regulations specifically warn against boil-and-bite options for this reason, mandating custom-fitted mouthguards for all players.

Custom mouthguards stay firmly in place during athletic activity, eliminating the constant adjusting and repositioning that plagues over-the-counter options. Your child can breathe normally, speak clearly to teammates and coaches, and focus entirely on their performance rather than dealing with an ill-fitting piece of equipment. This improved compliance means the mouthguard actually gets worn consistently—and a mouthguard sitting in a gym bag offers zero protection.

The Custom Mouthguard Process at Brooks Pediatric Dentistry & Orthodontics

Creating a custom mouthguard for your young athlete involves a straightforward process that delivers exceptional results. During your initial visit to our office on SE Military Drive, one of our board-certified pediatric dentists will evaluate your child's oral health, discuss the specific sport and level of play, and determine the optimal mouthguard specifications.

We then take detailed impressions or digital scans of your child's teeth and surrounding structures. These impressions capture every contour, cusp, and characteristic of your child's unique dental anatomy. Modern digital scanning technology has made this process even more comfortable for young patients, eliminating the gagging sensation sometimes associated with traditional impression materials.

The impressions are sent to a specialized dental laboratory where skilled technicians fabricate your child's custom mouthguard using high-quality, medical-grade materials specifically designed to withstand athletic impacts. These materials are far superior to the thermoplastic used in boil-and-bite options, offering better durability, shock absorption, and longevity.

When your child's mouthguard is ready—typically within a week—you'll return to our office for a fitting appointment. Our pediatric dentists carefully check the fit, making any necessary adjustments to ensure perfect contact, comfort, and protection. We'll show your child how to properly insert and remove the mouthguard, discuss care and maintenance, and answer any questions about optimal usage.

For children with braces or other orthodontic appliances, custom mouthguards are even more crucial. Brackets and wires can cause severe cuts to lips, cheeks, and gums during impacts, turning what might have been a minor collision into a painful soft tissue injury requiring stitches. Custom mouthguards designed for orthodontic patients provide a protective barrier between appliances and delicate oral tissues while maintaining the protection that teeth themselves need.

Addressing Common Concerns About Custom Mouthguards

Some San Antonio parents hesitate to invest in custom mouthguards due to concerns about cost, especially when their child is still growing and may need replacements as teeth shift and jaws develop. While custom mouthguards do cost more upfront than boil-and-bite options—typically ranging from $200 to $600—this investment delivers value that extends far beyond the price tag.

Consider the math: a single dental emergency visit can cost $500 or more, before you even begin addressing the actual injury. Treating a knocked-out tooth, chipped incisor, or broken jaw involves multiple appointments, potentially years of ongoing care, and expenses that dwarf the cost of several custom mouthguards. Many dental insurance plans provide coverage or rebates for custom mouthguards, recognizing their role in preventive care. It's worth checking with your insurance provider about available benefits.

Custom mouthguards also last significantly longer than over-the-counter options when properly maintained. High-quality materials resist wear and tear better than the softer thermoplastics used in boil-and-bite guards, which often need replacement multiple times per season. One custom mouthguard can typically last an entire season or longer for athletes whose dental development has stabilized.

For growing children, we do recommend checking the fit of custom mouthguards regularly—ideally at the start of each sports season—to ensure they still fit properly as teeth erupt and jaws develop. This preventive approach ensures your child always has optimal protection, even as their mouth changes. Some children may need annual replacements during periods of rapid dental development, but the superior protection justifies this investment.

Real-World Impact: Preventing Life-Changing Injuries

The pediatric dentists at Brooks Pediatric Dentistry & Orthodontics have treated countless sports-related dental injuries over the years, and we can tell you from experience that the severity of these injuries often correlates directly with mouthguard quality—or lack thereof. We've seen children suffer tooth avulsions, jaw fractures, extensive soft tissue lacerations, and complex dental trauma that required immediate emergency intervention and years of follow-up care.

In many cases, these injuries occurred while the child was wearing a mouthguard—just not one that provided adequate protection. A boil-and-bite mouthguard that had loosened during play, a stock mouthguard that never fit properly in the first place, or an over-the-counter option that had been repeatedly remolded until it no longer provided meaningful coverage. These scenarios play out with heartbreaking regularity in dental offices throughout San Antonio.

Contrast this with the experiences of young athletes wearing properly fitted custom mouthguards. While no protective equipment can prevent 100% of injuries, custom mouthguards dramatically reduce both the incidence and severity of dental trauma. Athletes experience minor impacts that would have resulted in broken teeth with inferior protection, yet walk away unscathed thanks to superior shock absorption and force distribution.

Custom mouthguards may even provide protection beyond dental structures. Emerging research suggests that properly fitted mouthguards might help reduce the risk and severity of concussions by stabilizing the jaw and preventing it from being jammed forcefully into the skull during impacts. While mouthguards aren't a concussion cure-all, this additional potential benefit provides yet another reason to choose professional-grade protection.

Making the Right Choice for Your Young Athlete

Your child deserves the absolute best protection available when they step onto the field, court, or rink. Sports offer tremendous benefits for physical health, mental development, and social growth—but these benefits shouldn't come at the cost of permanent dental damage that could have been easily prevented.

The choice between a $15 boil-and-bite mouthguard from the sporting goods store and a custom mouthguard from Brooks Pediatric Dentistry & Orthodontics isn't really about price comparison. It's about whether you want adequate protection or optimal protection. It's about choosing between convenience and effectiveness. And it's about deciding whether saving money upfront is worth the risk of facing devastating dental injuries and the massive expenses that follow.

At our practice serving Brooks City Base, Downtown San Antonio, South San Antonio, and surrounding neighborhoods, we're passionate about keeping young athletes safe. Our board-certified pediatric dentists combine specialized training in children's dental health with a genuine commitment to preventive care that protects your child's smile for a lifetime.

Protect Your Child's Smile This Sports Season

Don't let another practice or game go by with inadequate protection. If your child participates in any contact sport or activity where facial impacts are possible—which includes far more than just football and hockey—a custom mouthguard should be considered essential equipment, just like cleats and shin guards.

Schedule an appointment at Brooks Pediatric Dentistry & Orthodontics today to have your young athlete fitted for a custom mouthguard. Our team makes the process quick, comfortable, and stress-free, and we'll ensure your child leaves our office with professional-grade protection that fits perfectly and performs flawlessly. Contact us at 210-801-9715 or visit our convenient location at 2302 SE Military Dr #101, San Antonio, TX 78223.

Your child's smile is priceless. Protect it with equipment that works as hard as they do.

‍